PAGE 1
NORTHWEST COAST
STONE CLUBS
OREGON, WASHINGTON & BRITISH COLUMBIA
est. A.D. 1 TO EUROPEAN CONTACT

PAGE 1 OF 1 PAGES
COPYRIGHT DECEMBER 31, 2013 PETER A. BOSTROM
Abstract image of northwest coast stone club and mask.
NORTHWEST COAST MASK AND STONE CLUB

Abstract image of northwest coast club and masks.

ABSTRACT
NORTHWEST COAST STONE CLUBS
NORTHWEST COAST

est. A.D. 1 TO EUROPEAN CONTACT

    This article illustrates and describes several examples of stone and one Nootka style whale bone club from areas along the northwest coast of the U.S. and Canada. Of the twelve examples illustrated, eight are drawings of clubs that are computer altered with stone textured surfaces to make them look more realistic. These clubs show a range of style, from simple to refined artistic examples. Northwest coast clubs were used for dispatching animals, close combat fighting, and for dress & ritual activities. They were in use for approximately 2,000 years.

     "These people (Nootka people, British Columbia) have bows, and arrows, spears, slings, short truncheons (clubs) made of bone and a small pick-axe---. From the number of their weapons it may be reasonably concluded, that they engage frequently in close combat; and we had very disagreeable proofs of their wars being both frequent and bloody, from the quantity of human skulls that were offered to us for sale."--------1784-1786, Captain Cook, from account of Captain Cook's third voyage within bound text published in 80 parts, George William Anderson, "---Complete Collection Of Voyages Round The World---Captain Cook's First, Second, Third And Last Voyages,---" p. 541.
    "Every tribe in America used clubs, but after the adoption of more effectual weapons, as the bow and the lance, clubs became in many cases, merely a part of the costume."
--------1912, Frederick Webb Hodge, "Handbook Of American Indians North Of Mexico," Smithsonian pub., p. 313.
    "Nonutilitarian items (
in Prince Rupert II culture, British Columbia graves) include copper objects, amber and shell beads, shell gorgets, stone and bone clubs, ground and flaked stone daggers, labrets, pendants, and sea otter teeth."--------1990, Knut R. Fladmark, Kenneth M. Ames, & Patricia D. Sutherland, "Prehistory Of The Northern Coast Of British Columbia" Handbook Of North American Indians, Northwest Coast, Vol. 7, p. 234.
    "--the stone and bone clubs, bipointed ground stone objects, and ground slate daggers (used by Prince Rupert II culture people) are clearly weapons."------1990, Knut R. Fladmark, Kenneth M. Ames, & Patricia D. Sutherland, "Prehistory Of The Northern Coast Of British Columbia" Handbook Of North American Indians, Northwest Coast, Vol. 7, p. 234.
    "---the males (in Prince Rupert II culture, British Columbia graves) show unusually high levels of trauma including parry fractures of the forearm and depressed skull fractures."--------1990, Knut R. Fladmark, Kenneth M. Ames, & Patricia D. Sutherland, "Prehistory Of The Northern Coast Of British Columbia" Handbook Of North American Indians, Northwest Coast, Vol. 7, p. 234.
     "The size and shape of these (skull) fractures (in Prince Rupert culture, British Columbia burials) closely match the knoblike butts of stone clubs, which also first appear in this period, ca 1700 years before present"---------1983, George MacDonald, "Prehistoric Art Of The Northern Northwest Coast," Indian Art Traditions Of The Northwest Coast," p. 110.
     "---while the Indians of the northwest coast possessed projectile weapons, they relied much more on hand weapons. Clubs and daggers made of stone, bone or hardwood were their favorite arms."----1976, Robin Fisher, "Arms And Men On The Northwest Coast," BC Studies, No. 29, Spring 1976, p. 5.
    "Clubs made of stone or bone were, after all, just as effective for killing enemies as iron daggers"
---------1976, Robin Fisher, "Arms And Men On The Northwest Coast," BC Studies, No. 29, Spring 1976, p. 6.
    "A series of interesting paddle-shaped clubs, ancient and modern, often with carved handles, are found in the culture area of the Salishan tribes (northwest coast of Oregon, Washington & British Columbia). They are from 18 to 24 inches long, made of bone, stone, wood, and rarely copper"---------1912, Frederick Webb Hodge, "Handbook Of American Indians North Of Mexico," Smithsonian pub., p. 314.

Abstract image of northwest coast stone club and mask.
 
NORTHWEST COAST STONE CLUBS
NORTHWEST COAST

est. A.D. 1 TO EUROPEAN CONTACT

     Northwest coast clubs were made in such a wide variety of sizes and designs that many of them seem to have been made as one-of-a-kind styled clubs. But there are many that do seem to follow a certain typology. Stone clubs are unique for the fact that they are complete fighting weapons, just as they were made, without any additional hafting elements. They were produced in the northwest coast of North America and no where else on the continent. The oldest stone clubs were produced at least 2,000 years ago in Oregon, Washington and British Columbia. Stone clubs served as utilitarian tools for dispatching animals and for fighting. They also served as nonutilitarian tools for display and ritual. Some of the more skillfully crafted examples have impressed scholars and collectors for their artistic design since the late 1800's. Very few stone clubs have been reported from scientific excavations. Most are reported as random finds.

Three views of a stone club from Lewis Co,, Washington.
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
STONE CLUB
LEWIS COUNTY, WASHINGTON

    This stone club is reported to have been found in Lewis County, Washington on the Chehalis River in 1916. It was once in the Charles Miles and Claude Stone collections. This skillfully crafted club has a recurved edge and a diamond cross section. The end of the handle is drilled through from both sides with large conical holes. It was manufactured by hammerstone pecking and grit polishing. The handle has slightly more polish than the blade. This stone club measures 15 1/8 inches (38.4 cm) long.

     Estimated dates for northwest coast stone clubs range from 500 B.C. to European contact. One documented club, that was excavated in Prince Rupert harbour on the Kitandach site in central British Columbia, dates to sometime between A.D. 1 and A.D. 500. It's described as a simple form with a ribbed blade and a phallic designed handle end. The earliest evidence for the use of stone clubs is found on the bones of Period II (Middle Pacific) burials. They show a high incidence, in male burials, of forearm fractures called parry fractures and skull depression fractures. The skull fractures match the knoblike handle ends on stone clubs.

Six computer generated clubs from drawings, NW coast.
COMPUTER ALTERED DRAWINGS FROM 1910, "THE ARCHAEOLOGY OF THE YAKIMA VALLEY."
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
STONE CLUBS
YAKIMA VALLEY, WASHINGTON

    These six stone clubs are illustrated from drawings that are computer altered with stone textured surfaces. They represent different styles of stone clubs from the area in and around Yakima Valley, in south central Washington.

     The most significant and largest discovery of northwest coast stone clubs was found in 1898 by Chief Johnny Muldoe. He found a cache of 35 clubs while digging a hole for a house-post in the First Nation Village of Hagwilget in central British Columbia. They are reported to have been found approximately four to five feet below the surface. Most of them are carved with either bird or mammal head forms and thirteen have phallic designed handle ends. One example is carved with a human head on the end of the handle. The most peculiar aspect about the Hagwilget cache clubs is that they are described more as emblems of clubs rather than true fighting weapons. Some of them are either to small, delicate, or made from soft sandstone to serve as effective weapons. Duff (1975) writes that, "One of the most curious things about the stone clubs is they are not so much functional weapons as they are images of weapons."

Computer altered drawing of stone club from Oregon.
COMPUTER ALTERED DRAWINGS FROM 1912 "Handbook Of American Indians North Of Mexico," Smithsonian pub.
STONE CLUB
OREGON

    This stone club is illustrated in two views from drawings that are computer altered with a stone textured surface. It's reported to have been found in Oregon. The handle is perforated with a conically drilled hole. It's design features are parallel engraved grooves from end-to-end and two small extended "wings" on the end of the handle. This stone club measures slightly over 18 inches (46 cm) long.

    There is a wide range of style and quality of manufacture for northwest coast stone clubs. They vary from simple undecorated forms to complicated stylized forms with carved animal ornamentation. Lesser artistic examples were used for dispatching animals or fighting. The more delicate and rare complex forms were used for display & ritual. Stone pestles as long as 24 inches were also made in the northwest coastal area and they may represent the seeds of development for stone clubs.

Two effigy carved stone and bone clubs from NW coast.
PHOTO CREDIT LITHIC CASTING LAB'S COLLECTION OF ORIGINAL IMAGES
AND COMPUTER ALTERED DRAWING FROM 1910 IMAGE

"DECORATED" STONE & BONE CLUBS
NORTHWEST COAST

    Both of these clubs were found on sites in the northwest coast. They are ornamented with a common theme of carved animal heads on the end of the handles. The example on the left is made of stone and is illustrated from a drawing that is computer altered with a stone textured surface. It's reported to have been found at Lake Chelan in north central Washington. The design on the end of the handle is described as a heart-shaped animal head. Both the handle and the blade are nearly circular in cross section. It measures 11 inches (28 cm) long and it's suggested that this club may be "a ceremonial implement." The club on the right is a Nootka style club made of whale bone. Some bone clubs were made from the jaws of killer whales. This club is decorated with a carving of a Thunderbird head on the base of the handle. It was most probably collected from a tribal group that once lived along the seaward coast of Vancouver Island, Canada and the Olympic Peninsula of Washington state.

     Abnormally small clubs and especially elaborate stone clubs have been reported that would have no practical use as weapons. They probably functioned as either  items of display or possibly as shamanic tools used to battle evil forces. Shaman's tool kits often contained ceremonial weapons for fighting. Small bone pendants in the shape of clubs are reported that measure 2 or 3 inches (5 or 8 cm) long. Some of the clubs in the Hagwilget cache were made of soft stone and have delicately carved projections that would easily break if used for striking.

Stone club from northwest coast.
PHOTO CREDIT LITHIC CASTING LAB'S COLLECTION OF ORIGINAL IMAGES
COMPUTER ALTERED IMAGE

CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
STONE CLUB
NORTHWEST COAST

    This rough and heavy duty looking stone club is reported to have been found somewhere in the northwest costal region.

     Northwest coast clubs were made of stone, bone and wood. The largest number were probably made from wood. Basalt and serpentine are two of the hard stones that were used to make stone clubs.  They were also made from soft stone, such as sandstone. Bone clubs are identified as whale bone. Some examples were made from the jaws of killer whales. Clubs made of wood were made from hardwoods such as maple.

Whale bone club from northwestern U.S.
PHOTO CREDIT LITHIC CASTING LAB'S COLLECTION OF ORIGINAL IMAGES
COMPUTER ALTERED IMAGE

NOOTKA STYLE WHALE BONE CLUB
NORTHWEST COAST

    This style of this northwest coast club is called a Nootka club or a Wakashan club. Nootka refers to a tribal group that once lived along the seaward coast of Vancouver Island, Canada and the Olympic Peninsula of Washington state. Wakashan refers to the combined Nootka and Kwakiutl groups of that time that formed the Wakashan language family. The Nootka of today includes addition tribes who also speak the Wakashan language.
    This picture shows a "classic" example of a whale bone club from the Nootka Sound area in British Columbia. The bird head on the base of the handle represents the mythological and supernatural thunderbird creature. The thunderbird is revered in the art, song and oral histories by different native American groups across North America. A common belief was that it caused thunder and stirred the wind by moving its large wings. This club represents a standard design model from this area of the northwest coast. Captain Cook is reported to have collected at least eight similar bone clubs at Nootka Sound when he visited there on his third voyage in March of 1778. He reports in his journal that, "These people have bows, and arrows, spears, slings, short truncheons (clubs) made of bone and a small pick-axe---." He also comments that, "From the number of their weapons it may be reasonably concluded, that they engage frequently in close combat; and we had very disagreeable proofs of their wars being both frequent and bloody, from the quantity of human skulls that were offered to us for sale."

     Writers often comment about the similarity of the stone clubs used by the Maori of New Zealand to those found in the northwest coastal area of the U.S. and Canada. Although most of the northwest coast clubs are not similar in design to Maori clubs, enough examples have been found with perforated handles and wide blades to offer an argument of similarity. What is most interesting is that both cultural areas were using stone clubs at the same time from the 17th century into the 19th centuries. The Maori began using them very late compared to those used in the northwest coast. Fighting clubs, made only of stone, are so rare in the world it's hard to believe the two locations were not in contact with each other. But separate invention of similar tool types and technology is not unknown. The northwest coast stone clubs are more bulkier than the Maori clubs which are ground and polished to thin and sharp edged blades.

Comparison: 3 NW coast clubs to 1 New Zealand stone club.
PHOTO CREDITS, PETE BOSTROM &
LITHIC CASTING LAB'S COLLECTION OF ORIGINAL IMAGES &
COMPUTER ALTERED IMAGES
DRAWINGS FROM 1910, "THE ARCHAEOLOGY OF THE YAKIMA VALLEY."
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
COMPARISON:
NORTHWEST COAST & NEW ZEALAND CLUBS
NORTHWEST COAST U.S. AND NEW ZEALAND

      Writers often comment about the similarity of the stone clubs used by the Maori of New Zealand to those found in the northwest coastal area of the U.S. and Canada. Although most of the northwest coast clubs are not similar in design to Maori clubs, enough examples have been found with perforated handles and wide blades to offer an argument of similarity. What is most interesting is that both cultural areas were using stone clubs at the same time from the 17th century into the 19th centuries. The Maori began using them very late compared to those used in the northwest coast. Fighting clubs, made only of stone, are so rare in the world it's hard to believe the two locations were not in contact with each other. But separate invention of similar tool types and technology is not unknown. The northwest coast stone clubs are more bulkier than the Maori clubs which are ground and polished to thin and sharp edged blades.
    These four clubs illustrate some of the similarities writers refer to when comparing New Zealand stone clubs to northwest coast stone clubs. The three clubs on the left are from sites in south central Washington and the stone club on the right is a typical example from New Zealand. The illustrated clubs in the center are from drawings that were computer altered with a stone textured surface. The club on the left is perforated on the end of the handle with a conically drilled hole and in that respect it's similar to the New Zealand club on the right. Another similarity are the wide blades on the two northwest coast clubs in the center. They compare in outline fairly well to the New Zealand club. What sets the two types of clubs apart, is the New Zealand clubs are much more highly refined with polished surfaces, thin blades, sharp edges and some were made from jadite. The northwest coast clubs do not have sharp edges or thin blades and most of them do not have holes on the ends of the handles. The surface finishes are also not nearly so well smoothed and polished as New Zealand stone clubs.

     Clubs have been described as ambiguous things that have two meanings. They can be tools for life-taking or they can be seen as tools for life-preserving. The living hand on the handle activates the process of life and death. Current evidence seems to show that northwest coast stone clubs were used in close combat fighting in attacks where no quarter was given.

"REFERENCES"

1784-1786, Cook, James, from account of Captain Cook's third voyage within bound text published in 80 parts, George William Anderson, "---Complete Collection Of Voyages Round The World---Captain Cook's First, Second, Third And Last Voyages,---".
1910
, Smith, Harlan I., "The Archaeology Of The Yakima Valley, Vol. VI, Part I".
1910
, Moorehead, Warren K., "The Stone Age In North America, Vo. II."
1912
, Frederick Webb Hodge, "Handbook Of American Indians North Of Mexico," Smithsonian pub.
1960
, Strong, Emory, "Stone Age Of The Columbia River."
1962
, Gunther, Erna, "Northwest Coast Indian Art."
1963
, Miles, Charles, "Indian & Eskimo Artifacts Of North America."
1965
, Hawthorn, Harry B., "Cultures Of The North Pacific Coast."
1971
, Inverarity, Robert Bruce, "Art Of The Northwest Coast Indians."
1975
, Duff, Wilson, "Images Stone B.C., Thirty Centuries Of Northwest Coast Indian Sculpture."
1976
, Fisher, Robin, "Arms And Men On The Northwest Coast," BC Studies, No. 29, Spring 1976.
1981, Stewart, Hilary, "Artifacts Of The Northwest Coast Indians."
1983
, MacDonald, George, "Prehistoric Art Of The Northern Northwest Coast," Indian Art Traditions Of The Northwest Coast," p. 110.
1986
, Fladmark, Knut R., "British Columbia Prehistory."
1990
, Fladmark, Knut R., Ames, Kenneth M., & Sutherland, Patricia D., "Prehistory Of The Northern Coast Of British Columbia" Handbook Of North American Indians, Northwest Coast, Vol. 7.
1991
, Fane, Diana, Jacknis, Ira & Breen, Lise M., "Objects Of Myth And Memory, American Indian Art At The Brooklyn Museum."
1995
, Matson, R. G. & Coupland, Gary, "The Prehistory Of The Northwest Coast."
2003, Edwards, Philip, "James Cook, The Journals."
2010
, Hoover, Alan L., "Northern Northwest Coast Stone Clubs," American Indian Art Magazine.
Personal Communication
, Mike Gramly

RECENT LISTINGS    HOME    ORDERING