PAGE 1
BIRDSTONES
EASTERN UNITED STATES
LATE ARCHAIC-EARLY WOODLAND
PAGE 1 OF 2 PAGES
COPYRIGHT MAY 31, 2009 PETER A. BOSTROM
Birdstone and other artifacts, Caldwell collection.
PHOTO BY DENNIS VESPER--OF CLEM CALDWELL COLLECTION
BIRDSTONE
EASTERN UNITED STATES

   This beautiful popeyed birdstone was photographed a few years ago on one of Clem Caldwell's shelves of artifacts. The precarious position of the birdstone was Clem's standard technique of displaying his artifacts. He was known for keeping them stacked in these seemingly dangerous positions. This popeyed is made of a beautiful piece of porphyry.
    Other artifacts in this picture include some wonderful examples of Woodland period platform pipes. The birdstone is setting on a bannerstone.

Abstract image of birdstones.

ABSTRACT
BIRDSTONES

EASTERN UNITED STATES

LATE ARCHAIC TO EARLY WOODLAND PERIOD

    This article illustrates and describes several examples of birdstones from the eastern U.S. These enigmatic artifacts are made from ground and polished stone and date from the Late Archaic to the Early Woodland periods. Many suggestions have been made as to their use but to date no absolute proof explaining their purpose has ever been discovered.

    "The probability--is that these bird-stones were used or worn by the men rather than by the women, and Cushing's theory that they were attached to a plate and fixed to the hair is plausible."---1919, Frederick Webb Hodge, "Bird-Stones," Handbook of American Indians North Of Mexico, part 1, p. 148.
     "Gillman was informed by an aged Chippewa, "that in olden time these ornaments were worn on the heads of Indian women, but only after marriage," and suggests that the birdstones may have symbolized the brooding bird."
---1919, Frederick Webb Hodge, "Bird-Stones," Handbook of American Indians North Of Mexico, part 1, p. 148-149.
    "It may reasonably be concluded from the uniform shape of these (birdstones) articles, and from their apparent unfitness as implements, as also from the wide range of their occurrence, that they were invested with a conventional significance as insignia or badges of distinction or as amulets"---1848, E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis, "Ornaments Of Stone, Bone, Etc.," Ancient Monuments Of The Mississippi Valley, p. 239.
    "The underside (
of birdstones) is flat or slightly concave, and there are two perforations at the extremities of the base intended to serve in attaching the figure to the surface of some object, as a tablet, a pipe stem, a flute, or a staff or baton, or some part of the costume, or to the hair."---1919, Frederick Webb Hodge, "Bird-Stones," Handbook of American Indians North Of Mexico, part 1, p. 148.
    "They (
birdstones) appear in two types, the plain bar; called bar amulet, or with the upper face more or less resembling a sitting bird, with an expanded tail, and head with projecting eyes, called bird amulet."---1898, Frederick H. Williams, M.D., "Amulets," The American Archaeologist, Vol. 2, No. 8, pp. 200-202.
    "While they (
birdstones) bear a greater resemblance to birds than any thing else, yet scarcely any two of them are alike, and they change in form through the whole gamut until it is difficult to determine whether it is a bird, a lizard, or a turtle, and finally the series ends in a straight bar without pretense of representing any animal."---1896, Thomas Wilson, "Prehistoric Art; Or The Origin Of Art As Manifested In The Works Of Prehistoric Man," Report Of The U.S. National Museum, p. 450.

"Popeye" birdstones.
 
BIRDSTONES
EASTERN UNITED STATES
LATE ARCHAIC TO EARLY WOODLAND PERIOD

   The earliest writers have always referred to these abstract images in stone as bird effigies. Most people have no problem identifying them with birds even though they are found in many different abstract or highly stylized forms. For more than 150 years they have been referred to as birds, bird shaped objects, bird amulets and finally the descriptive term used today, birdstones.

1848 illustration of birdstones.
 ILLUSTRATION FROM 1848 SMITHSONIAN PUBLICATION
BIRDSTONES
EASTERN UNITED STATES

     These three drawings represent some of the earliest illustrations of birdstones. They were published in 1848 in Squier and Davis's, "Ancient Monuments Of The Mississippi Valley." The first publication by the Smithsonian.

     No one knows what birdstones were used for. Absolute proof of what their drilled holes and flat undersurfaces were attached to has never been found. But there are many suggestions. Most of these ideas originate from different cultural artifacts that seem to have a similar theme or shape and were used in either ceremonial or utilitarian applications. Some of these suggestions are: they were attached to the prow of canoes, mounted on staffs, attached to flutes, used as atlatl weights, used as atlatl handle grips, attached to long smoking pipe stems, or that they may represent fetishes or talismans that were fastened to such things as games bags or arrow quivers, or that they may represent effigies of duck decoys and even that they may have been carried by medicine men.

Illustration of six different forms of birdstones.
 ILLUSTRATION FROM 1912 SMITHSONIAN PUBLICATION
BIRDSTONES
EASTERN UNITED STATES
LATE ARCHAIC

   These six drawings of birdstones illustrate several of the different "main" forms. The two birdstones at top represent one of the most elaborate types. Both have popeyes but one has feet and the other does not. The next two represent the most common style. One has a short body and the other is the elongated form. Notice also that one has a mouth and the other does not. One survey of 1,000 birdstones showed that 10.7% had incised mouths. The two bottom examples are the simplest forms of birdstones. The example on the left still has a recognizable head and tail but the example on the right only has two raised ridges to represent the head and tail. The one on the right is also referred to as a bar amulet.
    Birdstones have been found in an endless variety of form. Dr. Thomas Wilson is quoted in Moorhead 1917: "The United States National Museum posses many of these specimens (birdstones). While they bear a greater resemblance to birds than anything else , yet scarcely any two of them are alike and they change in form through the whole gamut until it is difficult to determine whether it is a bird, a lizard, or a turtle, and finally the series ends in a straight bar without pretense of presenting any animal."

      Birdstones date from the Late Archaic to the Early Woodland periods. Only a handful of them have been found during the excavation of burials. Two bar style birdstones are reported to have been found in the head area of a single adult on the Baker II Late Archaic site in Sandusky  County, Ohio. The Baker II site dates to the terminal Late Archaic period at 2,820 years ago. A popeyed style birdstone is also reported to have been found during the excavation of an Early Woodland burial containing three individuals on the Danbury site in northern Ohio dating to around 2,500 years ago. Bust type birdstones have also been reported from Early Woodland Adena mounds. Birdstones are also associated with Glacial Kame sites.

"Popeyed" birdstone from Ohio.
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
POPEYED BIRDSTONE
HANCOCK COUNTY, OHIO

    This popeyed birdstone was found in 1926 by J. D. Alspach in Hancock, County near Vanlue, Ohio. It represents one of the more artistic forms and has the more rarely seen addition of "feet." Most birdstones do not have any projection on the bottom but instead have smooth flat undersides. They are also drilled on the front and back corners indicating they were once attached to some object. This birdstone is drilled through both "feet." The hole in front can be seen in this picture. This birdstone is made of porphyry and measures 3 1/4 inches (8.2 cm) long.
   The extra effort that is applied by the sculptor to enhance the eyes of these types of birdstones would seem to suggest an intention to convey strength in vision. One interpretative concept of this train of thought might be, the more powerful the eye sight the more knowledge that can be possessed, delivered or conveyed.

     There are three basic styles of birdstones which evolved into many different distinct types. The more common type is known as the elongated form. They are usually made of banded slate, have long bodies with long "beaks," and have no eyes. The saddle form is another type. It has eyes and is usually made of porphyry or granite. The third and rarest form is the bust type. This type has no body except for a head neck and shoulders. They are often made from some of the hardest stone, such as granite or quartz.

Fantail birdstone from Vermont.
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
FANTAIL BIRDSTONE
CHITTENDEN COUNTY, VERMONT

    This fantail birdstone was found in 1846 by S. H. Baker in Chittenden County one mile north of Burlington, Vermont. This is another of the more rare and beautiful forms of birdstones. It was made from a colorful stone and its complex style includes "feet," a large rectangular head, and wide tail. It's also drilled through both "feet."  This birdstone is made of porphyry and measures 4 1/2 inches (11.4 cm) long.

     Birdstones have been found in many states east of the Mississippi River and in an area in southeastern Canada. More specifically, approximately 95% of them have been found in New York, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Wisconsin, Michigan and in the lower region of eastern Canada. The greatest number of birdstones have been found in Ohio and Michigan. The state of Indiana has produced the third largest number. The core area where most birdstones have been found is located in northeastern Indiana, northwestern Ohio, southeastern Michigan and the southern part of Ontario.

Banded slate birdstone.
SHORT BODY BIRDSTONE
EASTERN UNITED STATES

     This banded slate birdstone represents one of the more common short body styles. Most birdstones were made of banded slate. This birdstone is drilled at the bottom corners at the front and back and it has the typical flat bottom.

     Birdstones were made from several different types of hard and soft stone. By far the largest number, in fact most of them, are made from banded greenish gray slate. Birdstones were also made from: different forms of granite, porphyry, quartzite, quartz, diorite, gneiss, serpentine, hematite, soapstone, sandstone, limestone, shale, indurate clay and Ohio pipestone.

"Bust" type birdstone from Erie County, Ohio.
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
BUST BIRDSTONE
ERIE COUNTY, OHIO

    This bust birdstone was found in 1977 by Earl Devereaux on a small shale bar in the Huron River in Erie County near Milan, Ohio. Bust birdstones are the rarest type. Only the head, neck and shoulder are represented, unlike most birdstones which have full bodies. Bust birdstones are also often made from harder stones. This birdstone is made of granite and measures 3 3/16 inches (8.1 cm) long.
   Bust birdstones are the most recently made types. They date to the Early Woodland period and have been found on Adena sites.

    Birdstones represent one of the most impressively crafted ground stone artifacts found in North America. The fact that they were made from durable materials suggests that these were important objects. The more elaborate popeyed, fantail or long bodied styles would have required a fair amount of skill and time to make them.

CONTINUE ON TO PAGE TWO

"REFERENCES"

1848, Squier, E. G. & Davis, E. H., "Ornaments Of Stone, Bone, Etc.," Ancient Monuments Of The Mississippi Valley, p. 239.
1896
, Wilson, Thomas, "Prehistoric Art; Or The Origin Of Art As Manifested In The Works Of Prehistoric Man," Report Of The U.S. National Museum, p. 450.
1898
, Williams, Frederick H. M.D., "Amulets," The American Archaeologist, Vol. 2, No. 8, pp. 200-202.
1912
, Hodge, Frederick Webb, "Bird-Stones," Handbook Of American Indians North Of Mexico, pp. 148-149.
1917
, Moorhead, Warren K., "Stone Ornaments Used By Indians In The United States And Canada," p. 88.
1959
, Townsend, Earl C., "Birdstones Of The North American Indian," pp. 3.
1975
, Tiell, William W., "The Incised Mouth Birdstone," Ohio Archaeologist, Vol. 25, No. 3, pp. 20 -21.
1979
, Fincham, Glenval, "A Novel Explanation Of The Origin And Development Of The Birdstone," Ohio Archaeologist, Vo. 29, No. 4, p p. 14-15.
1984
, Illustration, "Central States Archaeological Journal, Vol. 31, No. 3" p. 135.
1993
, Zakucia, John A., "The Birdstone, An Enigma Of The Prehistoric Past," Ohio Archaeologist, Vol. 43, No. 1, p. 27.
2003
, Skrivanie, Oliver T., "The Fab Five," Prehistoric American, Vol.37, No. 2, p. 4.
2004
, Power, Susan C., "Early Art Of The Southeastern Indians Feathered Serpents & Winged Beings," p. 28.
2006
, Werness, Hope B., "Bird," Animal Symbolism In Art, p. 44.
Personal Communication, Dennis Vesper.
Clem Caldwell Collection Pictures, Dennis Vesper.

RECENT LISTINGS    HOME    ORDERING