PAGE 1
CRAIG MOUND &
ROBERT BELL
SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD CADDOAN CULTURE
800 A.D. TO 1450 A.D.
PAGE 1 OF 1 PAGES
COPYRIGHT JULY 31, 2010 PETER A. BOSTROM
Colorful blade excavated from Craig Mound.
COLORFUL BIFACE FROM CRAIG MOUND

Abstract image of Pacola Mining Company members.

ABSTRACT
CRAIG MOUND & ARTIFACTS
SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE

   This article illustrates and describes some of the artifacts that were found during the Pocola Mining Company's excavation of Craig Mound on the Spiro Mound site in Le Flore County, Oklahoma. Also, several pictures from professor Robert Bell's black and white photo album are used to illustrate some of the different stages of the excavation. They show the early relic hunting excavations of the Pocola Mining Company and the later WPA salvage excavations of what was left of the great mound. Some of the black and white photographs have been colorized.
   Recommended reading: "The Spiro Mound: A Photo Essay" by Larry and Christopher Merriam, This book is illustrated and written around professor Robert E. Bells personal collection of photographs of the excavations of Craig Mound that he took in the years 1935 and 1937.

   "This mound (Craig Mound) undoubtedly contained one of the richest deposits of archaeological materials that has been discovered in the united States."---1980, Joan S. Gardner, "The Conservation Of Fragile Specimens From The Spiro Mound, LeFlore County, Oklahoma," p. 1.
    "There were three kinds of mounds at Spiro. One type was raised as a platform for a structure; the second was an earth cover for a destroyed building; and the third is what is called an accretional burial mound, one built up of increasing layers of burials, burial goods and earth.."---1981, Barbara Page, "Spiro Mound Artifacts Reveal 12th Century Culture," The Gilcrease Magazine Of American History And Art,  p. 7- 8.
   "The most distinctive feature of the site (
Spiro Mound) was the saddle-shaped mound known as The Spiro Mound or the Great Temple Mound, (It has been renamed the Craig Mound---)."---2004, Larry G. Merriam & Christopher J. Merriam, "The Spiro Mound: A Photo Essay," p. 5.
    "Spiro Mound was part of the greater Spiro Mound site located in eastern Oklahoma on the south bank of the Arkansas River."
---2004, Larry G. Merriam & Christopher J. Merriam, "The Spiro Mound: A Photo Essay," p. 5.
    "The Spiro artifact record is primarily a corpus of grave goods, but despite its specialized nature it is one that sheds great light on Mississippian cultural systems throughout the southeast."
---1976, James A. Brown, "Spiro Studies, Volume 4," p. IV.
    "The privileged were honored at death with special treatment, and the mounds result from the highly complex ritual associated with the burials of the dead elite."---1981, Barbara Page, "Spiro Mound Artifacts Reveal 12th Century Culture," The Gilcrease Magazine Of American History And Art,  p. 7.

Abstract image of Craig Mound pipe.
 
CRAIG MOUND & ARTIFACTS
SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE

    Some of the photographs in this article were taken by professor Robert Bell in 1935 and 1937. Robert Bell was born in 1914 in Marion, Ohio and is now deceased. He became interested in archaeology at an early age and began attending Ohio State University in 1936. He also attended the University of New Mexico and later the University of Chicago where he received his PhD.  He accepted a teaching position at the University of Oklahoma and  was curator of Archaeology at the Stovall Museum of Science and history at the University of Oklahoma.


CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGE IMAGE OF BOTTLE
PHOTO FROM ROBERT BELL'S PHOTO ALBUM----LITHIC CASTING LAB COLLECTION OF IMAGES.
COLORIZED AND ALTERED BY PETE BOSTROM

MR. COLUMBUS EUBANKS & WIFE ODA
HOLDING HUMAN EFFIGY BOTTLE

SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE
(PICTURE CAPTION CORRECTED AS PER LARRY MERRIAM 8/31/10.
NEW INFORMATION HAS MADE A POSITIVE IDENTIFICATION OF THE PEOPLE IN THIS PICTURE
AS MR. COLUMBUS EUBANKS AND WIFE ODA, NOT MR. R. W. WALL AS PREVIOUSLY REPORTED IN THE BOOK)

     This picture shows Mr. Columbus Eubanks standing next to his wife Oda. Mr. Eubanks was hired by the Pocola Mining Company to dig at Craig mound. He may have been paid with artifacts. He is holding a human effigy water bottle that was dug from Craig mound and sold to Harry Bell. This photograph was taken on April 9, 1936 and it was taken from Robert's Bell's original photo album. This black & white photograph has been colorized and altered with a different sky background.
    The human effigy bottle that Mr. Eubanks is holding was purchased by Robert Bell's father, Harry T. Bell, on the same day the picture was taken. The bottle is described as a kneeling female figure with incised hands in the area of the stomach. The ears are pierced and there is a topknot on top of the head. The facial features are rather unique. The eyes and mouth were formed with a stamp. Another oval design was also stamped onto the center of the forehead. Bottles like this may have been used to hold either water or seeds.

     Robert Bell became interested in the excavation of Craig Mound from the very beginning. He visited the site in the Spring of 1933 and again when the Pocola Mining Company began digging the mound late in the same year. He also visited the site in 1934 but didn't start taking photographs until he visited again in 1935 for an extended stay. He visited the site again in 1937 and photographed the project when WPA workers were excavating the remaining mound structure.

Colorful blade from Craig mound.
COLORFUL BIFACE
CRAIG MOUND
SPIRO MOUND SITE

LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA

    This is one of the most remarkable bifaces or flint blades ever found in the United States. Its color and banding pattern is really quite extraordinary. Bill or Hayden Vandagriff discovered it sometime in April 1935. He found it while digging in one of the smaller mounds or cones located within the large saddle-shaped mound complex known as Craig Mound. Robert Bell bought it in 1935 for his dad for $15.00. It measures 13 1/8 inches long and 3/8 inch thick. Robert Bell identified the material as Kay County chert from northern Oklahoma but some believe it may be Kaolin chert from southern Illinois.
    This colorful biface was on exhibit in the "Hero, Hawk, and Open Hand: American Indian Art of the Ancient Midwest and South," exhibition. It was displayed at The Art Institute of Chicago and the St. Louis Art Museum.

     For drama in archaeology no one needs to look any further than the Pocola Mining Company's excavation of the great mortuary. The incident touches many emotions. The human drama involved everything from the protection of the spirits of the dead to the protection of scientific data and add to that a measure of profit and treasure. The event began with a small group of men who formed a business called the Pocola Mining Company who leased the largest mound structure on the Spiro Mounds site. Their crude project produced spectacular finds never seen before. The large numbers of artifacts probably even surprised the diggers. No one had ever found such a large volume of relics before. A collectors pamphlet printed in 1936 reports that, "The first digging began on the level terrace near the small end, and within 10 minutes, four ear spools and four copper needles were found."

Pacola Miners digging on Craig mound at Spiro Mounds site.
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
PHOTO FROM ROBERT BELL'S PHOTO ALBUM----LITHIC CASTING LAB COLLECTION OF IMAGES.
COLORIZED BY PETE BOSTROM
THE POCOLA MINING COMPANY
SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE

    This colorized image of a black and white photograph from Robert Bell's photo album was taken sometime in April 1935. It shows the excavation in progress by the Pocola Mining Company. The caretaker, known as Dan, is sitting in the back. The man standing to the left is Billy Vandergriff. The man standing to his right in the hole is W. Guinn Cooper and the man next to him is Hayden Vandergriff, who is Billy Vandergriff's brother. The man sitting to the right in the picture is Robert Bell's school friend Chuck Aronhalt. The caretakers tent, where he lived while protecting the site and where the artifacts were held before being sold, can be seen in the background. The location of the excavation is described as "the third cone from the north." The largest mound in the structure known as Craig Mound and where the great mortuary tomb was discovered, can be seen in the background to the left. The area where these men are digging is believed to be the general area where the colorful biface illustrated above may have been discovered.

    There was an immediate reaction from the scientific community. Forrest E. Clements of the University of Oklahoma Anthropology Department began a campaign to stop the destruction of the mound in 1934. The Pocola Mining Company mined the site for all it was worth until they were finally stopped by one of the first antiquities laws in the country that prohibited digging an archaeological site without a license. A 1936 collectors guide wrote that "When it was leaned that the boys of meager circumstances had really found something worthwhile, steps were immediately taken to enact a law forbidding them to excavate without a license."

5 views of frog pipe from Craig mound on Spiro Mounds site.
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
PRIVATE COLLECTION
FROG EFFIGY PIPE
SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE

    This effigy frog pipe is reported to have been discovered during the excavation of Craig Mound. It was originally published in the June 7, 1936 issue of the Daily Oklahoman. At least five frog pipes are reported to have been found on the Spiro Mound site. Brown describes them as a relatively common Mississippian pipe form. This is one of the nicest examples ever found. The style of this pipe indicates that it may have been made in the Cahokia Mounds area. The frog is sitting on a platform which is a common feature on other Cahokia style pipes. This pipe is made of flint clay.

    With each passing year, archaeological excavation and the artifacts recovered become more and more controversial. Native American Indian groups are concerned about the spiritual nature of artifacts and human remains. Archaeologists are concerned about protecting scientific data. Art professors and art museums are concerned about protecting and displaying artifacts as art. Collectors are concerned about continuing to own artifacts. As each group voices their concerns they can literally bring tears of emotion from individuals from another group.

Pacola miners standing near central tomb on Craig mound.
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
PHOTO FROM ROBERT BELL'S PHOTO ALBUM----LITHIC CASTING LAB COLLECTION OF IMAGES.
COLORIZED BY PETE BOSTROM
CRAIG MOUND AT "LARGE CONE"
TOMB OPENING

SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE

    This picture was taken sometime in the summer of 1935 possibly by H. T. Daniel. It shows the Pocola Mining Company excavation in progress where the tunnels have opened the main mortuary tomb. The two men on the right are W. Guinn Copper and Billy Vandergriff and the man on the far left is John Hobbs standing with an unknown person.
   Hundreds of people are said to have gone into the central chamber. One account describes the discovery of the central chamber, as the wall was cut through, "the dead air rushed forth, the stench from the inside was almost unbearable." Many well preserved burials were in the central chamber. One of the burials is reported to have had 32 spear points laying across its chest. The size of the teepee shaped chamber is estimated to have been 14 to 16 feet in diameter and 16 to 18 feet high. The walls were lined with cedar poles that leaned to the center apex of the ceiling and the floor was also covered with cedar poles. There were so many artifacts in the tomb that the Kansas City Star newspaper lamented that, "no scientific organization, museum, or wealthy individual had come forward with financial support to classify and preserve these relics as had happened with King Tut's tomb in 1922."
    According to John Hobbs account, some of the artifacts contained in the central chamber were, "7 large stone maces, 30 copper axes, 30 copper-covered wooden human head effigies, many t-shaped pipes (measuring up to 29 3/4 inc, 3 large effigy pipes, 18 copper-covered baskets, 32 spear points, 15 long knives, bird points, one or two gallons of pearl beads, 1200 pounds of shell beads, robs, blankets, copper sheets, 100 conch shell cups, ear spools, lead balls, pottery bowls and water bottles."
   Additional accounts by MacDonald and Groves describe some of the interior as, "On the south side of the room was a 14 pound stone effigy of a woman and an eagle signifying a union of the two. On the north side was another pipe of a woman kneeling before an alter with an offering in each hand and a baby in a cradle on her back." They also report 500 pounds of lead ore.

   After the Pocola Mining Company exited the site the great mound was excavated to ground level by WPA workers. The Work Projects Administration was formed by president Roosevelt and funded by Congress to employ millions of Americans to carry out public works projects. They successfully recorded all the remaining features and fragile organic artifacts that were so unique to this site.

Spud dug from Craig mound by Pacola Mining Company.
PRIVATE COLLECTION
SPUD
SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE

    This spud or "ritual axe" was photographed by Robert Bell. Brown identified this form of "ritual axe" as a socio-technic ceremonial celt elongated form. He observed that four ceremonial celts had hafting stains on the shank indicating they were once hafted onto handles. This example also has obvious hafting stains approximately one third of its length from the end of the stem. This inset picture shows a close-up view of the hafting stain.

    The cause of the greatest excitement of the Craig Mound excavation was the discovery of the Great Mortuary tomb where a hollow cavity preserved a large number of fragile items. Fantastic tales started to spread about an elaborate central chamber filled with wonderful treasures.  The chamber was described as King Tut's tomb and a tapestried "Chiefs Room" that contained an alter with a shrouded skeleton laying before it and an urn filled with pearls. The central chamber did contain several types of burials that ranged from simple bundles of bones to litter burials that held people of high status.


CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
PHOTO FROM ROBERT BELL'S PHOTO ALBUM----LITHIC CASTING LAB COLLECTION OF IMAGES.

COLORIZED BY PETE BOSTROM
WPA WORKERS EXCAVATING
THE LARGE MORTUARY MOUND

SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE

     This picture was taken by Robert Bell in 1937. The original black and white photograph has been colorized to highlight some of the features. By this time the Pocola Mining Company excavators were long gone and the WPA workers had taken over. The WPA excavated the site for several years beginning in June, 1936 to 1941. There are 27 people in this picture doing several different activities. At top left five men are standing around a water jug. Just to the right, at the top of the mound, a man has just thrown a shovel of dirt into the air. Nine or ten people in the picture are at work with shovels. At least five people are on the ground doing more detailed excavation. Remnants of the great mortuary floor plan area can be seen near the small cavity along the wall where three men are excavating caches of conch shells.

   Brown writes that, "The Spiro artifact record is primarily a corpus of grave goods---. and "---the potential the Spiro artifacts have in shedding light on a unique Mississippian Period site is excellent, primarily because of the extensive array of burial inventories with unparalleled diversity in grave goods." Most of the burials were accompanied with varying numbers and quality of artifacts. One burial contained, in addition to other artifacts, well over 100 conch shell dippers. Another is reported to have contained an estimated 3,000 arrow points.

5 human heads of copper, shell, stone & wood, Craig mound.
PHOTO FROM ROBERT BELL'S PHOTO ALBUM----LITHIC CASTING LAB COLLECTION OF IMAGES.
COLORIZED BY PETE BOSTROM
HUMAN HEADS CARVED IN
WOOD, SHELL, COPPER & STONE

SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE

    The excavation of Craig Mound produced what has been described as one of the "richest' collections of artifacts ever found in the United States. This picture illustrates some of the examples of human effigies that Robert Bell photographed during the excavations of the mound. The artifacts were made from several different types of materials. The two human faces at top right and left were carved in wood. The large central figure with a feather curling over the head is made of copper. The human face at lower left was carved from a piece of conch shell and the image at lower right is from a figure carved in stone.

    Arrow points were the second most numerous artifact found in Craig Mound. One cache of approximately 3,000 points is pictured in this article. The cache was discovered in April 1935 by the Pocola Mining Company excavators and sold to a secondhand furniture dealer from Indianapolis, Indiana for $100. Brown describes at least 35 different types of arrow points found during the WPA excavation of the mound. The numbers of points they found in individual burial caches range from 10 points to 206 points.

Cedar poles and shell caches on floor plan of central tomb.
PHOTO FROM ROBERT BELL'S PHOTO ALBUM----LITHIC CASTING LAB COLLECTION OF IMAGES.
COLORIZED BY PETE BOSTROM

CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
CEDAR POLES & SHELL CACHES
ON THE FLOOR OF THE CENTRAL CHAMBER

SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE

    This picture was taken in June of 1937 by Robert Bell. It shows two ladies looking down at the WPA excavation of the "great mortuary" floor plan where the Pocola Mining Company discovered an opening to the central chamber. Several caches of conch shells can be seen along with some of the original cedar poles that appear remarkably preserved.

      There were many spectacular artifacts found in Craig Mound. The most colorful item found in the mound was a large biface. The color of the stone is quite remarkable. A picture of it appears in this article.  It was discovered by Bill Heydon Vandagriff sometime in April 1935. He found it while digging in one of the smaller mounds located within the large saddle-shaped mound complex known as Craig Mound. Robert Bell bought it in 1935 for his dad for $15.00. It measures 13 1/8 inches long and 3/8 inch thick. Robert Bell identified the material as Kay County chert from northern Oklahoma but some believe it may be Kaolin chert from southern Illinois.

Spud excavated by Pacola Mining Company, Craig mound.
PRIVATE COLLECTION
SPUD
SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE

    This Kaolin spud or "ritual axe" was discovered by the Pocola Mining Company excavators in Craig Mound. It was photographed by Robert Bell and was once in Harry T. Bell's collection. Almost all of the flake scars have been removed by polishing. There are one or more nicks on the blade edge which is not uncommon on these types of polished spuds.

    One of the most important artifacts found during the excavation of Craig Mound was a small obsidian scraper. It was discovered in 1935 by artifact collector and dealer J. G. Bracklein in the east tunnel that was dug by the Pocola Mining Company. Bracklein was known as, "a dedicated amateur archaeologist who took great pride in his association with the Smithsonian." He donated the scraper and other artifacts from Craig Mound to the Smithsonian. The obsidian has since been identified as coming from a source located at Pachuca, Hidalgo, Mexico. There has always been some suspicion that direct contact with Mexico may have occurred with large Mississippian period sites such as Spiro or Cahokia. But little evidence in the form of physical artifacts has been found so far.

3 spuds excavated by the Pacola Mining Company.
PHOTO FROM ROBERT BELL'S PHOTO ALBUM----LITHIC CASTING LAB COLLECTION OF IMAGES.
SPUDS ("RITUAL AXES")
SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE

    This picture is from Robert Bell's photo album. It shows two of the spuds illustrated in this article. Many different types of spuds are reported to have been discovered in Craig Mound.

     The most valuable artifacts found in Craig Mound are the engraved shell items. Conch shell dippers were engraved with human figures, various kinds of animals and geometric designs that depict mythological creatures and scenes. These rarely preserved engravings actually illustrate much of the culture's history. Like finding an ancient library, unexpected and more than could have been hoped for.


CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
PHOTO FROM ROBERT BELL'S PHOTO ALBUM----LITHIC CASTING LAB COLLECTION OF IMAGES.
LARGE CACHE OF ARROW POINTS
SPIRO MOUND SITE
LE FLORE CO., OKLAHOMA
MISSISSIPPIAN PERIOD, CADDOAN CULTURE

    Large numbers of arrow points were found in Craig Mound. This picture was taken by Robert Bell of an incredibly large cache that is estimated to be around 3,000 arrow points. This cache was discovered in April 1935 by the Pocola Mining Company excavators and sold to a secondhand furniture dealer from Indianapolis, Indiana for $100. Brown wrote that "Projectile points are the second most numerous and diverse artifact category at Spiro." Thirty-five different types of arrow points were found in Craig Mound. The many caches found by the WPA salvage project ranged in size from 10 points to 206 points.

    If Craig Mound hadn't been excavated in the 1930's it would never have been excavated. Burial mounds are now protected by law and most everyone would agree rightly so. But as with most complicated issues there is a dilemma. Now that the digging of burial sites is a non issue, the discussion of it is unpleasant and awkward. But the dilemma is still fascinating all the same and will never go away. There is a good chance that other great mounds may also contain ancient and fragile libraries. But, unlike the human spirit, the physical objects will not last forever.

"REFERENCES"

1936, Groves, G. I., "The Great Temple Mound," The Indian Relic Collectors Guide, pp.22-28.
1935-1937
, Robert Bells original photo album of black and white photographs.
1952, Hamilton, Henry W., "The Spiro Mound," The Missouri Archaeologist, Vol. 14, October.
1975, Brown, James A. and Phillips, Phillip, "Pre-Columbian Shell Engravings From The Crag Mound At Spiro, Oklahoma", pp. 1-7.
1976, Brown, James A., "Spiro Studies, Volume 4," p. IV.
1980
, Gardner, Joan S., "The Conservation Of Fragile Specimens From The Spiro Mound, LeFlore County, Oklahoma," p. 1.
1981
, Page, Barbara, "Spiro Mound Artifacts Reveal 12th Century Culture," The Gilcrease Magazine Of American History And Art,  p. 7- 8.
1996, Fagan, Brian M., "The Oxford Companion To Archaeology", pp. 686.
2004
, Merriam, Larry G., & Merriam, Christopher J., "The Spiro Mound: A Photo Essay," p. 5.

RECENT LISTINGS    HOME    ORDERING